
Highlights
Age Groups Seen
- Adults
- Geriatrics
Languages
- English
Gender
FemaleLocations
- Martha's Vineyard Primary Care Clinic
- 1 Hospital Road, Oak Bluffs, MA 02557
- Get Directions
- phone: 508-684-4500
- fax: 508-684-4502
Expertise
Education
- Residency: Mount Sinai Hospital, 2016
- Medical Education: Yale New Haven Hospital, N/a, 2014
- Medical Education: Drexel University, 2011
Board Certifications
- Occupational Medicine: American Board of Preventive Medicine, 2017
- Internal Medicine: American Board of Internal Medicine, 2014
Insurance
- Blue Cross Blue Shield
- Cigna
- Harvard Pilgrim Health Care
- Humana
- Mass General Brigham Health Plan
- Mass Health
- MassHealth ACO
- Medicare
- Medicare ACO
- Tricare
- Tufts Health Plan
- United Health Care
- WellSense
Ratings & Reviews
4.9 out of 5
153 ratings, 61 reviewsThe Patient Satisfaction Rating is an average of all responses to the care provider related questions shown below from our survey. Patients that are treated in outpatient or hospital environments may receive different surveys, and the volume of responses will vary by question.
- Reviewed on 4/3/2026
Dr Donahue is thorough, kind, and willing to spend time.
- Reviewed on 4/2/2026
Dr. Donahue spent a long time with me. I have in the past felt as if I was being rushed but not on this visit. I really appreciate her time and knowledge.
- Reviewed on 3/28/2026
She is smart, open, and extremely capable. She listens. She has reviewed my chart before she comes into the exam room. Terrific
- Reviewed on 3/25/2026
I am almost [redacted] years old. Dr Donahue is the best doctor I have ever had.
- Reviewed on 3/13/2026
Very Caring and Wonderful. Easy to speak to and trusting.
- Reviewed on 2/27/2026
Dr. Donahue is very tuned in to issues that I may have. She's well informed about my health history and she is a great doctor coordinating all the different aspects of health.
- Reviewed on 2/27/2026
very pleased with her
- Reviewed on 2/25/2026
Calm and informative.
- Reviewed on 2/26/2026
It was excellent, excellent care. I have no complaints.
- Reviewed on 2/19/2026
Dr Donahue was attentive, professional and helpful. She addressed my concerns.
- Reviewed on 2/15/2026
I have nothing but respect for Dr. Donahue's continuing commitment to her vocation and I consider myself lucky to be part of her practice. [redacted]
- Reviewed on 2/5/2026
Very comfortable interactions. [redacted]
- Reviewed on 2/5/2026
Dr. Donahue has, in my experience, always been thoughtful, smart, attentive, and when necessary, gives good feedback. Thanks. I'd refer anybody to her. Thanks.
- Reviewed on 2/2/2026
All of my concerns were addressed and treated appropriately. I am more than pleased with the care received at this appointment.
- Reviewed on 1/22/2026
Dr. Donahue is remarkable in her attention to detail, her focused attention, her ability to make the patient feel as though she has all the time in the world, her pertinent questions and on-point suggestions. I feel fortunate to be able to have her as my physician.
- Reviewed on 1/19/2026
Nothing to say everything was perfect ?
- Reviewed on 1/18/2026
My wife has Alzheimer's and she is also under Dr Donahue's care. She is aware that being my wife's caregiver also can effect my health, and I am very grateful that she can see both of us and treat us as a family unit.
- Reviewed on 1/17/2026
Dr. Donahue is wonderful. She is kind, caring and truly takes the time to understand and figure out how to best help her patient. I am very thankful for her!
- Reviewed on 1/16/2026
Compassionate and very competent....I'm very happy with Dr D
- Reviewed on 1/15/2026
DR DONOHUE IS A FIRST CLASS, KNOWLEDGABLE PROVIDER WHO HAS A GREAT GRASP ON MY MEDICAL HISTORY. FRIENDLY,PROFESSIONAL AND THOUROUGH.
- Reviewed on 1/14/2026
GREAT PHYSICIAN
- Reviewed on 1/4/2026
I have been seeing Dr Donahue for several years since I moved to MV and I find her very good- she has been very attentive to all my ongoing medical needs and has made several referrals to specialists on my behalf- all within MV Hospital. Alethia is personable and speaks frankly regarding my 'health-path'. I feel lucky to have such a competent primary care provider and to have MV Hospital as my base for my health is amazing.
- Reviewed on 12/28/2025
Dr. Donahue is the absolute best. She truly cares about her patients, knows their history, and is an incredible advocate. Grateful to have her.
- Reviewed on 12/20/2025
Dr. Donahue exceeds expectations and is a dedicated and highly trained physician. She has been my Primary Care physician for 8 years and has proven to be thorough, and well educated in managing complex and nuanced health matters.
- Reviewed on 12/16/2025
I think she is an excellent physician
- Reviewed on 12/9/2025
Was great
- Reviewed on 11/29/2025
Dr Donahue is the best. I feel she cares about me, listens carefully and considers all options before making recommendations. I feel comfortable discussing any issues that come up. I trust her 100% and am very grateful for her
- Reviewed on 11/26/2025
Great doctor
- Reviewed on 11/23/2025
Dr Donahue has been on top of my care. She is he best!
- Reviewed on 11/20/2025
Very kind and respected my concepts of my health care
- Reviewed on 11/16/2025
Listened to my concerns and addressed them effectively
- Reviewed on 11/15/2025
Dr. Donahue is excellent. She is knowledgeable, professional, warm, engaged and engaging. She always treats me with respect and regard, and in a manner that makes me think very hopefully about my health at this ripe old age of 60!
- Reviewed on 11/12/2025
Great doctor.
- Reviewed on 11/8/2025
I feel very grateful to have Dr. Donahue as my primary care physician she listens she synthesizes and comes out with a plan together with you. It's perfect.
- Reviewed on 11/2/2025
Dr Donovan took my emergency personally and I was so lucky. She diagnosed pneumonia and ordered the most aggressive course of medication I have ever received for this annually recurring illness. I was very grateful for her vigorous review of my last couple yrs of history as I had been seeing her excellent RN Specialist mostly over that period. [redacted] Thank you
- Reviewed on 10/31/2025
Very earnest and intuative doctor but hard to see when needed.
- Reviewed on 10/30/2025
Dr. Donahue is thoughtful, kind and knowledgeable. I highly recommend her as a practitioner.
- Reviewed on 10/27/2025
Dr. Aletheia Donahue is the best. No matter what you ask her she knows the answer. She is friendly and curious and happy and really cares about her patients. ( five stars / Highest Rating )
- Reviewed on 10/16/2025
Time spent with the doctor was meaningful, insightful & reassuring.
- Reviewed on 10/15/2025
Dr Donahue has been my primary care physician for the past five years. Her care and concern has been and remains outstanding.
- Reviewed on 10/15/2025
I am fortunate to have Dr Donahue prescribe the tests that I need to check out my heart that may have some serious issues. She is following me closely and I am very thankful!
- Reviewed on 10/15/2025
I was in for physical with Dr. Donahue. She is terrific.
- Reviewed on 9/27/2025
She is careful and absolutely first rate when it comes to listening and, most important, diagnosis. We are grateful to have her here on island.
- Reviewed on 9/18/2025
I am very happy with Dr Donahue. I feel that she listens carefully to me as an individual.
- Reviewed on 9/18/2025
She the best!
- Reviewed on 9/4/2025
Dr. Donahue is a knowledgeable, caring and efficient provider!
- Reviewed on 8/29/2025
I'm so fortunate to have Dr Donahue as my doctor. She's very helpful and listens carefully. I am very grateful for all she's doing for me
- Reviewed on 8/26/2025
Excellent no problems at all
- Reviewed on 8/21/2025
Dr. Donahue is a superb professional and great family doctor. In one case her intervention for me was literally life-saving
- Reviewed on 8/19/2025
I I'm really happy to have Dr. Donahue as my primary care provider. Think her care and attention to detail is outstanding and I am very comfortable talking to her at any time about anything. She is able to think creatively and come up with possible scenarios or solutions to problems I may be having and I feel like she's very adept in all ways as a caring doctor.
- Reviewed on 8/15/2025
My doctor was unavoidably delayed, which I understand completely, but after 45 minutes no one came into the room to let me know! Another 15 minutes and I might have left, or more likely gone out to see if they had forgotten me. The doctor came in just before that and apologized and gave me all the time that I needed. So it worked out well.
- Reviewed on 8/6/2025
Dr Donahue is top notch. Professional but caring
- Reviewed on 8/4/2025
Well, it was just a splendid appointment. It covered the things that we wanted to talk about. And I think this is a superb physician. And I think the hospital is doing quite well. And I'm happy with being a part of it. Thank you. Bye bye.
- Reviewed on 7/27/2025
I am a lucky person to have the care provider and team that I do.
- Reviewed on 7/20/2025
This was the best MVH experience I have ever had. MD scheduled enough time for a very productive visit
- Reviewed on 6/29/2025
positive
- Reviewed on 6/25/2025
Dr. Donahue is a Compassionate, caring listener who pays attention to what you want and need in striving to be healthier.
- Reviewed on 6/18/2025
Dr Donahue is an extremely competent and caring physician who listens, discusses & explains the medical issues of concern. I feel very comfortable i am received superlative care by Dr Donahue and her health care team,
- Reviewed on 6/19/2025
She listens carefully and respectfully and collaborates on treatments and care.
- Reviewed on 6/18/2025
Happy with the care I was given
- Reviewed on 6/5/2025
Dr. Donahue spent plenty of time discussing some ivital issues with me. She made sure I understood their importance. I appreciate her care.